You're creating content. You're showing up. Maybe you've even been at it for months, and yet your audience isn't really growing. It's frustrating, especially when you see other people seemingly blow past you with less effort.

Here's the thing: most people who struggle to grow their audience aren't failing because they're untalented or lazy. They're making a handful of very specific, very fixable mistakes. And I know this from seven-plus years of working with online entrepreneurs — watching some grow their audiences quickly and watching others spin their wheels for a long time before something finally clicked.

I've made most of these mistakes myself, by the way. So this isn't a lecture. It's more like a debrief from someone who's been there.

Let's get into it.

Embed Block

Enter a valid embed URL or code.

Mistake #1: Poor Packaging

This is the most common reason audiences don't grow, and it's the one most people least want to hear.

Your content might be genuinely good. But if it doesn't look good, most people will never find out.

We're living in an era of content overload. Every single day, people scroll past thousands of videos, articles, posts, and podcasts, and they make split-second decisions about what to pay attention to. In that context, packaging isn't shallow. It's survival.

"Packaging" goes further than you might think. For a YouTube video, it includes your thumbnail, your title, your lighting, your video quality, even what you're wearing. For a blog article, it includes your formatting, font choices, and how easy the page is to scan. For a podcast, it includes your episode title, your cover art, and your show description.

Think of it like a book on a shelf. You might judge it by the cover — the design, the title, what the back cover says. That's all packaging. And the person browsing that shelf is making a snap judgment about whether to pick it up.

If your packaging isn't working, even amazing content can go unnoticed. If you've been creating for a while and not seeing growth, this is the first thing to look at honestly.

Mistake #2: Inconsistent Output

Consistency is one of those words that gets thrown around so much it's almost lost its meaning. But it matters more than almost anything else when you're building an audience!

Inconsistency isn't just about posting schedule. It has three different forms:

Inconsistent schedule

You post sporadically, with long gaps and bursts of activity, so no one knows when to expect you.

Inconsistent topic

You post regularly, but each piece of content is about something different. Business tips one week, personal development the next, travel the next. There's no throughline.

Inconsistent style

Same topic, same schedule, but the format, tone, or production style changes so much that it doesn't feel like a single channel or brand.

Any of these creates the same problem: when someone stumbles across your content and enjoys it, they go check out your channel or profile and they don't see a clear picture of what following you would actually give them. So they don't follow.

I experience this as a viewer all the time. I'll find a YouTube video I love, click on the channel hoping I've discovered someone new to watch regularly, and find that that video was a total one-off. The rest of the content isn't what I came for. As a result, I don't subscribe.

The fix is to get clear on what you're consistently delivering, and then actually deliver it consistently.

Mistake #3: Doing Too Much

This one might be counterintuitive. You'd think more content on more platforms would equal faster growth, but it usually doesn't.

There are two versions of this mistake:

Version one: You're producing so much content that quality suffers. You don't have enough time, ideas, or energy to make each piece genuinely good — so you end up publishing a lot of mediocre content instead of a smaller amount of excellent content.

Version two: You're spreading yourself across too many platforms. YouTube, Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, Pinterest, a podcast, maybe some paid ads, all at once. You're essentially dividing your effort into dozens of small pieces rather than putting real momentum behind any one thing.

There's a diagram in the book Essentialism that captures this perfectly. When you try to do everything, you end up barely moving the needle on any of it. When you focus your energy on one thing, you can actually build momentum — and momentum is what eventually creates the snowball effect that makes audience growth feel almost automatic.

I learned this the hard way. When I was first trying to grow my audience, I was everywhere. And my audience wasn't really growing anywhere. The thing that changed everything was committing to YouTube — just YouTube — for at least three months. It worked so well that I stuck with it for years before branching out.

Pick one platform. Go deep. Get traction. Then expand.

Mistake #4: Content That's Too Vague

This one is harder to define, which is fitting, since vagueness is kind of the whole problem.

Some creators consistently produce content that's broad, general, and high-level. Topics like "how to improve your mindset" or "why success takes time" or "the secret to fulfillment." Big ideas, loosely explored. Not much that connects to specific, real-world problems people are trying to solve.

This type of content tends to underperform for a few reasons. First, it's harder to click on. The title doesn't make a clear promise, so there's less reason to care. Second, even if someone clicks, the content often doesn't hold their attention because it doesn't feel directly relevant to their life. And third, it doesn't give them a strong reason to subscribe, because they're not sure what you're actually going to help them do.

The fix isn't to never be philosophical or big-picture. It's to make sure that even your bigger ideas are grounded in specifics. Real examples, real challenges, and real experiences your audience is actually going through.

Ask yourself: would someone who's dealing with a concrete problem feel like this content was made for them? If the answer is no, get more specific.

Mistake #5: Talking About Unpopular Topics

You need an audience of people who are interested in your topic — and that requires that your topic actually has an audience.

This doesn't mean you need to chase trends or only make content about things that are already going viral. But it does mean making sure there are enough people out there who care about what you're talking about to actually build something.

A helpful check: is there meaningful search volume for the topics you're covering? Keyword research tools (for YouTube search, Google, or wherever you're publishing) can tell you whether people are actively looking for this content. If the numbers are very low, that's a signal worth taking seriously.

Your common sense counts here too. Are you part of communities or groups where people regularly ask about these topics? Do you see strong engagement when you touch on them? Those are good indicators.

One thing to watch out for: in the interest of "picking a popular topic," some people overcorrect and go very broad, which loops right back into Mistake #4. The goal isn't to be generic. It's to be specific about something people actually want.

You can absolutely include some content about topics you find important even if they're not widely popular yet, as long as the majority of what you produce is clearly in demand.

Which of These Is Holding You Back?

These five mistakes aren't equally common, and they're not always equally easy to spot from the inside. If your audience isn't growing and you're not sure why, the honest answer is to look at each of these with fresh eyes. Maybe even ask someone you trust to give you a real assessment.

For what it's worth, the one that held me back the longest was doing too much. I was trying to be everywhere, and it spread my effort so thin that I never got traction anywhere. Once I focused, everything changed.

If growing your audience is a real priority for you right now — and you want guidance on exactly which platform to focus on, what content to create, and how to actually build momentum — I'd love to have you in Build Your Audience Bootcamp. It's a six-month program where I walk you through the whole thing from start to finish, including some collaborative strategies that work across any platform.

You can join the waitlist at https://gillianperkins.com/build — enrollment opens soon.

5 Reasons Your Audience Isn't Growing (And How to Fix Them)

Mistake #1: Poor Packaging